The military government also controlled the palestinian population remaining in israel by policies of separation and isolation, policies not applied to the jewish population. Resolution 242 these resolutions are qualitatively different from the wellknown resolution 242, the socalled land for peace resolution, which requires action by other states and by nonstate actors, as well as israel. Shortly after the 1967 war, israel illegally annexed east jerusalem and declared it part of its eternal, undivided capital. Resolution 242 is one of the most widely affirmed resolutions on the arab israeli conflict and formed the basis for later negotiations between the parties. Resolution 242 1967 does not explicitly require that israel withdraw to the lines. Even as the council is poised to revisit the legacy of resolution 242. The security council, expressing its continuing concern with the grave situation in the middle east, emphasizing the inadmissibility of the acquisition of territory by war and the need to work for a just and lasting peace in which every state in the area can live in security. Israel did not accept this as a valid reason for lack of documents. That procedure, followed with egypt in 197779, led to egypts recognition of israel and israels withdrawal from the sinai. Dec 11, 2018 the us joint chiefs of staff recommended that for israel s security necessities, that it hold on to at least 40% of the territory between the jordan river and the green line.
The real failing of resolution 242 was that it regarded the palestinian arabs as merely homeless refugees, not a stateless nation, and the. Resolution 242 is one of the most widely affirmed resolutions on the arabisraeli conflict and formed the basis for later negotiations between the parties. Jul 24, 2016 i think it would be best for you to examine your question before stating that israel did or did not do something. Jarring mission special representative to middle east appointed under res.
United nations resolution 242 council on foreign relations. The middle east conflicta brief background global issues. A negotiated peace did seem possible once, almost 30 years ago. The central concept in the resolution was an israeli exchange of land won in the 1967 war the sinai peninsula, the golan heights, portions of. The territorial issue needs to be addressed realistically. Israel and the real failing of resolution 242 world. While the camp david accords were negotiated over a few days in the summer of 1978, they were actually the result of months of.
The resolution became the context and framework for subsequent official arabisraeli negotiations. Israel announced that it accepted security council resolution 242 and was ready to negotiate with each arab state on each element in that resolution. Resolutions 242 and 338 call for israel s withdrawal from territories as part of a peace agreement. This principle was the reason why israel agreed to accept the resolution of november 22, 1967, for not only did it accord recognition. The 19491967 lines are not even referred to in the resolution. Resolution 242 was formally accepted by israel in may 1968 but was rejected by palestinian leaders for 21 years, and they did not fully accept it until 1993. Washington claimed the role of the honest broker while proudly asserting its continuity as israel s major financial, diplomatic and military backer. This would take time, obviously, but time seemed to be on israels side, and the israelis had officially made it clear that they did not intend to return to the former.
Meanwhile, united nations security council resolution 242, which israel and the arab states have each signed onto, effectively supersedes unga res. Israel contends that resolution 242 requires each of its neighbors to recognize israels right to exist and to negotiate bilaterally a secure border. The united states has long said it would not deal with the p. Resolution 242, interpretation and implications cjpme english.
The twostate solution to the israelipalestinian conflict envisages an independent state of palestine alongside the state of israel, west of the jordan river. Opinion israels 1967 victory is something to celebrate. For israel, resolution 242 was a tool to reach unilateral agreements with arab countries without making any concessions on its military occupation of east jerusalem, the west bank and the gaza strip. The boundary between the two states is still subject to dispute and negotiation, with palestinian and arab leadership insisting on the 1967 borders, which is not accepted by israel. Israel will never negotiate from or return to the lines of partition or to the 1967 borders. Johnson said, now, finally, let me turn to the middle eastand to the tumultuous events of the past months. I think it would be best for you to examine your question before stating that israel did or did not do something. The us, while referring to resolution 242 as the ostensible basis of its own peace process, kept israel palestine diplomacy under its own control. Resolution 242 was approved on november 22, 1967, more than five months after the war. Israel views moves by palestinian leaders to obtain international recognition of a state of palestine as being unilateral action by the palestinians and inconsistent with a negotiated twostate solution.
Prior to the vote on the british draft that became resolution 242, the representative of the soviet union said, we understand the decision taken to mean the withdrawal of israel forces from all, and we repeat, all territories belonging to arab states and seized by israel following its attack on those states on 5 june 1967. Security council resolution 242 1967 of 22 november 1967 also known as. International law and israeli settlements wikipedia. Aware of arabs past aggression, resolution 181, in paragraph c, calls on the security council to. Jul 30, 2006 a series of targetted assassinations by israel against hamas and hezbollah, and resulting violent retaliations escalated in mid2006 with the capture of israeli soldiers. Israel, however, did not accept the resolution and continues to violate it to this day, over 50 years later, by building settlements on the territories meant for a palestinian state. United nations resolution 242 this resolution, which was adopted at the end of the sixday war, was an effort by the security council to resolve the border issues between the arab nations and israel. Parallel realities resolution 242 and the aftermath of 1967. The us, while referring to resolution 242 as the ostensible basis of its own peace process, kept israelpalestine diplomacy under its own control.
Determine as a threat to the peace, breach of the peace or act of. The real failing of resolution 242 was that it regarded the palestinian arabs as merely homeless refugees, not a stateless nation, and the underlying assumption was that the west bank or. The resolution acknowledges the arabs rights to these lands, and israel s right to peace and security. Resolution 242 was passed on 22 november 1967, a few months after israel had acquired large. Security council adopted resolution 242, which called on israel to relinquish some unspecified part of the territory it had conquered, providing the arabs signed on to allow israel to live in peace, free from the threat of armed aggression. How a missing the enabled israeli occupation palestine. This resolution was a tortuously negotiated compromise between competing proposals. Recommending partition of the british mandate for pa. By the late 1980s, israel, most arab states, the plo, the united states, the soviet union and most of the nations of the world had accepted resolution 242 as the proper basis for a settlement of. That led to an escalation of conflict, with air strikes by israel against lebanon and hezbollah, destroying much of the main infrastructure. These led to peace treaties between israel and egypt 1979 and jordan 1994, as well as the 1993 and 1995 agreements with the palestinians.
So although arab officials claim resolution 242 requires israel to withdraw from. Gone was the need to recognize israel s right to exist or even to accept 242 and 338 as is. In most cases, documents were lost or destroyed during the 1948 war. Jan 26, 2018 prior to the vote on the british draft that became resolution 242, the representative of the soviet union said, we understand the decision taken to mean the withdrawal of israel forces from all, and we repeat, all territories belonging to arab states and seized by israel following its attack on those states on 5 june 1967. The grammatical construction of the french version of resolution 242 says israel should withdraw from the territories, whereas the english version of the text calls for withdrawal from territories. Withdrawal of israeli armed forces from territories occupied in the recent conflict. But if resolution 242 allows a partial withdrawal, then the proposed new resolutions would contradict and countermand the earlier resolution, to israel s substantial disadvantage. By jews for justice in the middle east published in berkeley, ca, 2001. History of the question of palestine question of palestine. But it must be prepared to withdraw as resolution 242 says from territories occupied in the recent conflict.
Israel would agree to accept a certain number of palestinians and the rest would be settled in a palestinian state outside israel. During that war, israel invaded and occupied gaza and the sinai peninsula, territory held by or belonging to egypt. Resolution 242 was to become the cornerstone of middle east diplomatic efforts. In the wake of the june 1967 six day war, united nations security council adopts resolution 242. The palestinians have accepted other offers, such as the security council resolution 242 in 1967 and the oslo accords, which promised them a meager 22 percent of palestine at best. But lord caradon of england, and eugene rostow of the u. Resolution 181 constituted legal authority for israels creation, or otherwise constituted recognition by the u.
Parallel realities resolution 242 and the aftermath of. The israeli government appears to maintain that the resolution does not. In return, after years of rejection of israel as part of the middle east, the arabs will accept and recognize israel s right to exist as a sovereign state within secure and defined borders in this region as they did, for example, in the vetoed security council resolution of. In an address to a conference of educators on june 19, 1967, five months before unsc resolution 242 was unanimously passed by the security council. Throughout 1972, and for much of 1973, sadat threatened war unless the united states forced israel to accept his interpretation of resolution 242 which the united nations passed following the 1967 six day wartotal israeli withdrawal from territories taken in 1967. No internationally recognized, secure border has ever defined the area of the west bank and gaza strip and nowhere does 242 require that palestinians be given any political rights or. Israels position was that in order to implement 242, the parties would have to meet facetoface and negotiate a peace treaty. The palestinians are not mentioned anywhere in resolution 242. The resolution was really the first attempt at land for peace. Security council resolution 242, which created a framework allowing for palestinian. It is important to stress that resolution 242 in no way called on israel to withdraw to the lines of june 4, 1967, before the outbreak of the sixday war. Israeli prime minister menachem begin and egyptian president anwar sadat won the 1978 nobel peace prize. Yet the accepted procedure to be followed in cases of clashing texts. The socalled peace process has always been nothing more than a fiction, which has always led to israel stealing more palestinian land.
The security council in resolution 242 formulated the principles of a just and lasting peace, including an israeli withdrawal from territories occupied in the conflict, a just settlement of the. Security council adopts resolution 242, calling for israeli withdrawal from territories occupied during the six day war and respect for the rights of all states to live in peace and security. Washington claimed the role of the honest broker while proudly asserting its continuity as israels major financial, diplomatic and military backer. Abba eban told george ball israel was willing to return most of the west bank to jordan. Therefore, according to resolution 242, israel was assigned rights and. Sres242 1967 of 22 november 1967 question of palestine.
Response from the affected parties not long after the united nations security council passed resolution 242, jordan and israel accepted the resolution. Not long after the united nations security council passed resolution 242, jordan and israel accepted the resolution. Still, the plo rejected the offer, also embarrassing the saudis in the process. Camp david accords, agreements between israel and egypt signed on september 17, 1978, that led in 1979 to a peace treaty between the two countries, the first such treaty between israel and any of its arab neighbors. United nations security council resolution 242 wikipedia. After denouncing it in 1967, syria conditionally accepted the resolution in march 1972.
The reagan administrations approach to middle east peacemaking. Nor did those involved in the negotiations and drafting of the resolution want such a requirement. Security council resolution 242 jerusalem center for public affairs. Resolution 242 in no way called on israel to withdraw to the lines of june 4, 1967, before the outbreak of the sixday war. United nations security council resolution 242 sres242 was adopted unanimously by the. In the pre1967 borders israel was barely 10 miles wide at its narrowest point. While resolution 242 called for israels armed forces to withdraw from territories occupied in the recent conflict, no resolution called for israel to hand over all of east jerusalem to a future palestinian state. It called for the withdrawal of israeli forces from territories occupied in the recent conflict and affirmed the right of every state in the region to live in peace within secure and recognized boundaries.
1266 1452 373 1468 693 1511 736 1454 1060 659 900 276 1271 124 237 538 399 1250 1021 46 1125 20 1320 180 753 665 1264 99 1031 832 703 1036 1021 71